Sepang, Malaysia, 10/12/99, 56 laps

Ferrari won the race, but lost the championship



Michael Schumacher surprisingly changed his mind from being not able to drive to being totally fit last week after heavy critics in Italian media. He returned to F1 in Sepang and showed everybody, that he is the best driver of the 90ies. During qualifying noone even came close to the times set by Schumacher. His teammate Eddie Irvine qualified second ahead of Coulthard and Häkkinen and both Steward drivers.

At the start of the race, the first two to three rows came off the grid without problems, so there was no change in position into the first corner. The field behind took advantage of the unusual broad track and you could see four or five cars side by side on the starting grid. In the first chicane, Damon Hill was hit by Fisichella from behind andfor the second race in a row did not make it through the first chicane. Fisichella's car was damaged, so he came into the pits, had his car repaired and after a couple of minutes rejoined the race.

Michael Schumacher was able to pull out an advantage of more than three seconds over his teammate within the first three laps. Coulthard followed Irvine closely and tried to attack. Championship leader Häkkinen left a small gap to Coulthard and was attacked by the Steward of Barrichello, but could hold him off. In lap four, Schumacher slowed down and Irvine could close the gap. Into the first gear chicane, Schumacher pulled to the right, let Irvine through and immediately blocked Coulthard from slipping through as well. The team order of the Ferrari team was applied earlier than expected. Only few laps later, Coulthard made a manoeuver on Schumacher within the section of the right-left-combination after the starting straight. Schumacher saw him coming on his inside and wisely pulled to the right to avoid contact. He succeeded in avoiding damage, but they touched softly as Coulthard's manoeuver was somewhat optimistic. Both cars continued: Coulthard hunted down Irvine and closed the gap and Schumacher did a good job in slowing down Häkkinen to maximize the gap between the championship rivals.

When Coulthard had reached race leader Irvine, he lost drive into the straight and soon afterwards came to an early halt. So Irvine lead the race and had schumacher behind him who kept Häkkinen from driving as fast as he could. When the first round of pit stops was nearing, Schumacher suddenly pulled away from Häkkinen and easily opened up a gap of a couple seconds within few laps. In doing so, he enabled himself to change tyres without a big threat from Häkkinen. That point showed the whole audience that Schumacher was not driving a race in the sense of racing round the track as fast as he could, but more in the sense of tactically helping a slower driver winning more points than he could if he was on his own. The sprint of about six laps was over, when both drivers, Schumacher and Häkkinen left the pits in the order of before the stops.

Irvine, who was the first of the leading trio to stop for tyres, clearly was on a two stop strategy, but for Schumacher and especially Häkkinen, you could not be sure. When Irvine stopped for the second time, the Ferrari team got some calculations wrong, because when he returned to the track, he found himself behind Schumacher and Häkkinen. At that point it was not yet clear whether the Finn had to stop once more, so Schumacher had to stay out as well. But luck was on teh side of Ferrari and the McLaren team called their driver in for the second stop. Surprisingly, Schumacher did not have to stop once more, but could go on till the race was over. Of course, he allowed Irvine once more to overtake and take the victory at the first Malaysian Grand Prix shadowed by Schumacher while crossing the checkered flag with Häkkinen not far behind.

Herbert succeeded with his one stop strategy and nearly was able to keep Häkkinen from re-taking his third position after teh Finns second stop. Fifth to cross the line was Barrichello and the last championship point went to Frentzen, who stopped only once after qualifying 15th due to problems with the car.

On the podium, the joy of the Ferrari people was overwhelming and their rival Häkkinen was completely out of shape. The Finn was physically totally exhausted and he hardly could stand on his feet during the ceremony. But his mood and constitution was to change dramatically soon.

Remarkable was Trulli, whose Prost car's engine blew up during the warm-up lap. Hill did not complete a kilometer in his second-last race in formula 1. Fisichella, after his first lap incident with Hill, rejoined the track after being scrutinized for four laps by his team and finished with only four laps down. That means the Italian did not lose too much ground compared to the other drivers after he really started his race. Gené finished ahead of the Williams of Zanardi and I am not aware of any too heavy weighing incidents with Zanardi, so the Minardi performed quite well.

As I know up to now, the cars of the three podium finishers were scrutinized after the race as usual. During these inspections, the stewards found out that an aerodynamical part of the Ferrari cars did not meet the regulations and therefore, both Ferraris were disqualified. The Ferrari team officially protested against the decision, but admitted that the part was illegal. Their justification (for the protest) is that the illegal part was already used at the last grand prix at the Nürburgring without being objected.

My (probably too fast and for sure personal) interpretation is that the Ferrari team saw their loss of competitiveness at the races in Spa and Monza and saw their only chance to win the championship in cheating a little. They knew that the modification could bring them a gain of speed and decided to use it and hope that it was not objected. Their excuse that they know that the part is illegal, but that they used the part earlier on without objection is naive and helpless. To my opinion, it is typical for this season that the championship, which now is decided in favour of Häkkinen, is not decided due to strengths of one team or driver, but more due to failures of the other team. The McLaren team was clearly superior concerning performacne of the car and the championship was only as tight as it was, because the McLarens lacked reliability and suffered from drivers errors. Ferrari throught out most of the season was not able to challenge the McLarens. Sadly but true.

The only hope that Ferrari can have is that the ilegal part did not have a performace increaing effect to their cars and in that case, the jury might classify the Ferraris, like the jury did last year with Coulthard and another driver last year, when they used wrong fuel, were disqualified, but later classified as the fuel did not affect their performance.

Good luck for all the teams and drivers for next year. Especially for Minardi, who seem to have overcome their financial problems with the help of Telefonica.

The classification before the disqualification was as follows:
1.IrvineIRLFerrari
1h36:38.494
2.M. SchumacherGERFerrari
1.040
3.HäkkinenFINMcLaren
9.743
4.HerbertENGStewart
17.538
5.BarrichelloBRAStewart
32.296
6.FrentzenGERJordan
34.884
7.AlesiITASauber
54.408
8.WurzAUTBenetton
1:00.934
9.GenéESPMinardi
1 lap
10.ZanardiITAWilliams
1 lap
11.FisichellaITABenetton
4 laps
 
Not classified:  
 VilleneuveCANBAR
8 laps
 DinizBRASauber
12 laps
 De la RosaESPArrows
26 laps
 BadoerITAMinardi
41 laps
 CoulthardSCOMcLaren
42 laps
 TakagiJAPArrows
49 laps
 R. SchumacherGERWilliams
49 laps
 ZontaARGBAR
50 laps
 PanisFRAProst
51 laps
 HillENGJordan
56 laps
 TrulliITAProst
56 laps


Surprisingly, the FIA court reinstalled this result. Dishonour goes out to all parties involved. I do not believe Ferrari that they did not use this part on purpose. I think it is disgusting how German media and Ecclestone demanded reinstallment of the race result in order to make another millions at the Grand Prix in Japan. They feared that in the main target market Europe noone would get up in the middle of the night to watch their commercials. McLaren representative Haug is a liar, who immediately after the race and for a couple of days pointed out that McLaren is in no way involved in the disqualification action. Meanwhile the same person admitted that it was the McLaren team who informed the stewards about the possible rule conflict of the Ferrari cars. Kick all of those people out of our Formula One!!