Nürburgring, Europe, 9/26/99, 66 laps

Minardi scores a point

Crazy race at the Nürburgring! Frentzen, who had qualified on the pole position made a false start, as well as Häkkinen, Schumacher and Trulli. The false start was caused by a defective starting device, so it was repeated without penalyzing any driver. At the second start, Frentzen could defend his second position into the first corner. But there an incident in the back of the field happened: Hill had problems with the electronics of his car and lost engine power totally. The following cars treid to avoid him. In doing so, Wurz had to brake hard and turn to the right. But on his right was Diniz in the Sauber. The wheels of the two cars touched and Diniz got airborne. The care tumbled into the grass and came to a halt on its top. The roll-bar of the Sauber broke and the damaged car looked very bad after the marshalls and doctors rescued Diniz out of the car. Diniz waving to the fans was releaving, but should not keep the teams from thinking about the stability of roll-bars. Only few weeks earlier in the same corner of the same track, a driver of the German Formula 3 championship had a similar accident in which his car slid across the track upside down with a broken roll-bar. The Dutch driver of that car now is paraplegic. The track or the corner is not the cause, but more the roll-bar has to be scrutinized ans possibly optimized and strengthened.

Ater the security car left the track, Frentzen could lead a group of four with Häkkinen following and Coulthard and Schumacher behind. The Ferraris of Irvine and Salo were a couple of positions behind, but at least Irvine was able to make up some ground. In the consequent laps, Schumacher was able to pass Coulthard, but the other positions remained stable. Then the sky darkened and the rain came. A couple of drivers came in for wet tyres, amongst them Häkkinen, but most of the other drivers stayed out. Stange things happened at the Ferrari pits, where Salo came in for new tyres, but the team was ready for Irvine, so they put the tyres of the Ulsterman on the car of the Finn. When Irvine came in for his tyres shortly afterwards, the team had only three tyres ready. It took quite long for Irvine to leave the pits. At that point Irvine had no prospects for a good result today. The only positive thing for him was, that for an unknown reason, Häkkinen was just behind him after the Ferrari came out of the pits. I could not find a reason for the Finn being so slow on his second set of tyres or in the wet, but obviously he had lost about 20 or so seconds within only few laps.

The leaders, Frentzen and Coulthard, came in for new tyres simultaneously and the Jordan team worked well to keep their car in front of the strong McLaren. But bad luck stroke the Jordan team soon afterwards for the second time today: Frentzen's car stopped right after the first chicane with the same symptoms as Hills car in the first lap, failure of electrical power. Coulthard inherited that position, but bad luck stroke him later. His teammate, championship leader Häkkinen dropped further and further back and struggled with Arrows and Minardis right at the back of the field. He was already lapped by the leaders at that point. Coulthard misjudged the wet track, that in the meantime after the first period of rain had dried out, but was wettened by a second batch of rain. He slithered off the track and softly into a pile of tyres and he could not move anymore.

So we saw another leader in this race. It was Ralf Schumacher, who performed very well in the rain, but as well in the dryer periods of the race. The Williams seems to be improved a lot compared to earlier races this year. The young German was comfortable in the lead, when the right rear tyre exploded and forced him to go off in the following corner. Luckily, Schumacher was at least able to avoid the wall, get back onto the track and into the pits for a new set of tyres. Surprisingly, the car survived the nearly full lap without any obvious harm, despite the usual bits of the tyre bashing onto the chassis in such a situation. With the newer tyres, Schumacher drove faster than the leaders, but has dropped back a couple of positions. The person who inherited the lead from Schumacher was the Italian Fisichella. His Benetton performed surprisingly well compared to the last performances of the cars. His lead was quite comfortable, but he spun only few laps afterwards and retired. It was very difficult to judge the grip of the track with temporal and spacial changing conditions.

When we looked at the classement at that point we saw Herbert in the lead, who only had stopped once in front of Trulli and Barrichello. Fourth was - believe it or not - Badoer in the Minardi in front of Schumacher, Villeneuve, the second Minardi of Gené and only then the championship leaders Irvine in 8th and Häkkinen in 9th. When the track started to dry out again at that point, Häkkinen was driving quick laps again. He closed down on Irvine and fought with him for 8th.

With 13 laps to drive, Badoer had to retire and give up the prospects for scoring points. But he handed a point scoring position to his teammate Gené, who moved up to sixth. While Barrichello was challenging Trulli for second, Häkkinen fought with Irvine for 7th. The Finn succeeded and tried to catch up with the Minardi for the last point. Only five laps from the checkered flag, bad luck stroke the BAR team for the umpteenth time this year and Villeneuve retired from his fourth position. This saw Häkkinen in the points and Irvine still outside. The Ferrari driver could not follow his rival, who in the second-last lap catched Gené's Minardi and therefore scored two valuable points today. Irvine could not catch the Minardi and stayed outside the points. Ralf Schumacher drove good laps for almost the whole race, but because of his tyre failure, he could only finish with three points in his hands.

The podium positions were occupied by a lucky winner Herbert, who earned the first vistory for the Stewart racing team in Formula One. Barrichello, who was held off by second man Trulli, even improved the best result of the Stewart team. The Italian Prost driver finished on the podium for the first time in his Formula One career.

Though it needed a lot of car control to stay on the track today, it needed a lot of luck to finish in the points. Some weeks ago, Irvine said it needs reliability and making no errors to win the championship, more than a fast car. He might be right and one should not blame the Ferrari team for his bad pit stop today. The Ferrari team does neither lack reliability of his cars, nor do their drivers make a lot of errors, but their car lacks of speed or setup. The main rivals in the championship retired or had massive problems today. Häkkinen struggled with Minardis and Arrows cars in the middle of the race, so they again seemed to have technical problems with their car, but the Ferrari could not take profit of it. If the Ferrari people can't change this status at the last two races, they simply do not deserve a championship. But the McLaren team does not deserve it as well. They were clearly ahead of the field at most of the races concerning speed, but their cars often had failures, their drivers and their pit crews made errors and their refueling equipment was not error-free as well. If the Jordan team were not a one driver team, they possibly could be classified higher in the rankings. With a second driver scoring more points, he could have stolen valuable points from Frentzen's rivals and he might be closer to the leaders or even ahead. Hill had only a couple of good results this year, but mostly he returned from the grand prixs with poor results. Possibly, he suffers from a streak of bad luck like Frentzen in his time at Williams, possibly Hill lacks motivation, possibly he lacks speed. Either way it is bad for the Jordan team. Let's hope that Damon Hill delivers in the last two races and leaves Formula One with performances worthy of an ex-world champion so that we not only remember him as a sportsman with a lot of fairness, but as a magnificient racing driver as well.

1.HerbertENGStewart
1h41:54.314
2.TrulliITAProst
22.628
3.BarrichelloBRAStewart
22.865
4.R. SchumacherGERWilliams
39.507
5.HäkkinenFINMcLaren
1:02.950
6.GenéESPMinardi
1:05.154
7.IrvineIRLFerrari
1:06.683
8.ZontaARGBAR
1 lap
9.PanisFRAProst
1 lap
10.VilleneuveCANBAR
5 laps
 
Not classified:  
 BadoerITAMinardi
13 laps
 De la RosaESPArrows
14 laps
 FisichellaITABenetton
18 laps
 SaloFINFerrari
22 laps
 TakagiJAPArrows
24 laps
 CoulthardSCOMcLaren
29 laps
 AlesiITASauber
31 laps
 FrentzenGERJordan
34 laps
 ZanardiITAWilliams
56 laps
 HillENGJordan
66 laps
 WurzAUTBenetton
66 laps
 DinizBRASauber
66 laps